Portable Air Cleaner (HEPA filter) buying guide

Choose only air cleaners that have mechanical filtration ( particulate filter media) with MERV 13 or higher or HEPA designation. Watch out for ionizers that can produce hazardous ozone. How to choose? There is help!

sources:

1) Air Quality Expert Marwa Zaatari
twitter.com/marwa_zaatari/status/1351279531806621696?s=20 and
twitter.com/marwa_zaatari/status/1439101884229423106?s=20

2)Environmental engineering professor, Dr Shelly Miller offers a report and air cleaner selection guide twitter.com/ShellyMBoulder/status/1389331569026899971?s=20

3) California Air Resources Board ww2.arb.ca.gov/list-carb-certified-air-cleaning-devices

4) Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers ahamverifide.org

5) DIY box fan filters (Corsi-Rosenthal boxes) cleanaircrew.org/box-fan-filters

Choose only air cleaners that have mechanical filtration ( particulate filter media) with MERV 13 or higher or HEPA designation.

Be aware of false marketing:

HEPA-like
HEPA-style
99% HEPA
HEPAsilent
HEPA Ultra
Ionic HEPA
HEPAFast
HEPA Efficiency
HEPA Functions
HEPA Action
Plasma HEPA
Super HEPA
HyperHEPA

are ALL subpar versions of what constitutes a HEPA air filter.

Stay away of fancy technology marketing:

Plasma wave
Fragrance Sponge
UV Light Sanitizer Eliminates
NCCO technology
Active oxygen generator
ionic purifier + composite catalyst
cold catalyst layer
negative ion generator
Bi-polar
PECO
PCO
Plasma
Cold Plasma

note: Ionization produces ozone, which is hazardous to health

Graph of Air cleaners

  • Start by the area of the room to be cleaned (y axis)
  • Consider cost (x axis)
  • and noise (look at color of the dot; <55 db at highest setting is probably a good level) colors = noise level expressed in db (decibel)
Portable Air Cleaners comparison graph, HEPA, MERV13, CADR, cost, db decibels noise
Marwa Zaatari’s graph comparing Portable Air Cleaners based on CADR, cost, and noise level decibels

*note: CADR stands for Clean Air Delivery Rate

January 18, 2021 original post / thread
April 3, 2021 update
June 1, 2021 update
Aug 22, 2021 update with Corsi-Rosenthal box fan filter

Latest Update

Latest graph and much more here!

Sept 18, 2021 update

Dr Shelly Miller – Report and Calculator

Environmental engineering professor, Dr Shelly Miller, offers a report here on air cleaners.

This spreadsheet is the Harvard-CU Boulder Portable Air Cleaner Calculator for Schools – it can help you determine what air cleaner to use based on the size of the room etc.

And this is a 5 minute video about how to use the Air Cleaner Tool

California Air Resources Board

Also, the California Air Resources Board has a big list of devices that they have certified. https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/list-carb-certified-air-cleaning-devices

Since 2010, all portable indoor air cleaning devices sold to people or businesses in California are required to be certified by CARB. As of October 2020, electronic in-duct air cleaning devices are also subject to the regulation. To be certified, all air cleaners must be tested for electrical safety. Electronic air cleaners must also be tested for ozone emissions and meet an ozone emission concentration limit of 0.050 parts per million (50 ppb). 

Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers

The Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers certifies air cleaners, so the AHAM Verifide seal is a good place to start. More resources here: https://ahamverifide.org/consumer-resources/

DIY box fan filters

Also known as a Corsi/Rosenthal box, this DIY method of building your own air filter with MERV13 furnace filters and a box fan are a cost-effective way to help clear indoor air from airborne virus particles!